In Hearts and Hands by O.Henry, we are told the story of a marshall and a criminal on a train. Henry uses multiple techniques to build up the reader’s trust of the two people’s identities as a marshall and criminal. These techniques include the description and social standings.
In the beginning of the story, the author gives a description of both the marshall and Mr.Easton. Mr.Easton is described as a person of “handsome presence with a bold, frank countenance and manner.” This gives the impression that Mr.Easton is a trustworth, honest young man. In contrast, the marshall is shown as “a ruffled, glum-faced person, heavily built and roughly dressed.” Based on appearance, the reader would assume that the marshall is the criminal and Mr.Easton is the marshall. This is because, in our society today, we are socially biased that a more kempt and tidy person is less likely to be a criminal. Through the description, the author of the story manipulates the reader to believe that Mr.Easton is the marshall.
Secondly, another way the author makes the reader believe that Mr.Easton is the marshall is through his social standing. While he is talking to Miss Fairfield, he talks about his money and his luxurious life in Washington. It is clear that him and Miss Fairfield are of the same social class — a high social ranking. This is another way a bias is used to manipulate the reader’s thinking. Often, in society, people believe that the richer and higher class citizens are expected to be well-behaved and set an example instead of committing crimes. By showing the reader what social class Mr.Easton is in, the author makes it seem as though Mr.Easton is the marshall.
Both of these factors lead up to the plot twist at the end of the story. Up to the plot twist, the glum-faced man is expected to be the criminal. O.Henry uses social biases of description and social standings to convince the reader of this. However, through the conversation of two nearby passengers on the train, the truth becomes revealed that Mr.Easton is the criminal and the other man is the marshall.